Nicholas of Myra
A bishop of the 300s who left almost no record, and a thousand years of stories.
Picture: Saint Nicholas, an icon by Aleksa Petrov, 1294, from the Church of St Nicholas at Lipnya, near Novgorod. Public domain.
Who was Nicholas?
Nicholas was bishop of Myra, a port on the south coast of today's Turkey, in the 300s. He wrote nothing, and no one who knew him wrote about him. Stories of his secret gifts and rescues spread from his tomb across East and West. The name Santa Claus comes from his Dutch name, Sinterklaas.
at a glance
His path, in order
- HeirGave his fortune away, the stories say
- BishopOf Myra, a Lycian port, in the 300s
- WonderworkerHis title in the Orthodox churches
- PatronOf sailors, children and merchants
- RelicsHis bones, taken to Bari in Italy in 1087
- SinterklaasThe Dutch gift-bringer of 6 December
- Santa ClausHis name, as New York said it
in numbers
- Times he threw gold into a house by night3
- A dowry for each of three sisters
- Their father caught him the third time
- Men of Bari, in Italy, who took his bones47
- Armed, in April 1087
- They tied up the four monks guarding the tomb
- Liquid drawn from his tomb in Bari each year50 ml
- At most, each 9 May
- Bari calls it manna, the Greeks myron
- Years from his death to the first story that he slapped a man1,000
- Set at the Council of Nicaea, first told about 1370
- The man was a follower of Arius, the priest the council condemned
did you know?
-
A footnote in the book of saints of Egypt's Coptic Church says he is “the true personality behind the story of St. Claus or Baba Noel”, as Arabic speakers call Father Christmas.
Coptic synaxarium, 10 Kiahk -
Nicholas is a patron saint of children. In much of medieval Europe, a boy was elected bishop on his feast day, 6 December. The Boy Bishop reigned until Holy Innocents' Day, 28 December, the feast of the baby boys King Herod killed.
Britannica, “St. Nicholas”
- Born
- In Patara, a port of Lycia, say his medieval biographers. The Coptic book of saints makes him a man of Myra itself. No record from his own time survives.
- Died
- At Myra, on 6 December. The year is unknown. The Golden Legend, a medieval book of saints' lives, says AD 343. The Catholic Encyclopedia says AD 345 or 352. Church calendars today say about AD 326 or about AD 342.
- Buried
- In a church outside Myra's walls. Most of his bones have been in Bari, Italy, since 1087. Venice keeps fragments.
- His name
- The Greek Νικόλαος, from the words for victory and people.
- Also called
- Nicholas the Wonderworker in the East, Nicholas of Bari in the West, and Sinterklaas in the Netherlands.
- Pronounced
- NIK-uh-lus of MY-ruh.
- Bishop of
- Myra, in Lycia, today Demre in Turkey, some time in the 300s.
- Wrote
- Nothing that survives.
- Status
- A saint to Catholics, Orthodox, Copts and Anglicans. Lutherans remember him too.
- Patron of
- Sailors, merchants, bakers, travellers and children, says the 1911 Catholic Encyclopedia. Also of Russia and Greece.
- In art
- A bishop with three gold balls or purses, for the dowries he gave three poor sisters. In icons, an old bishop with a high forehead and a white beard. About 1370, in a Latin book of saints, Petrus de Natalibus wrote that he is mostly painted without a mitre, a bishop's tall hat. The reason, he said, was that the Council of Nicaea took it from him for striking a follower of Arius, the priest the council condemned.
feast days
East and West
West
- May9
The coming of his relics to Bari, in the 1916 Roman Martyrology. In Bari it is the feast of the Translation.
- Dec6
Catholic optional memorial. Also the Church of England, the Episcopal Church, and Lutherans in the Missouri Synod and the ELCA.
East
- May9
The coming of his relics to Bari, in the Orthodox Church in America (OCA) and other churches on the new calendar that keep it.
- May22
The coming of his relics to Bari, in the Russian Church, on the old (Julian) calendar, 13 days behind.
- Dec6
The day he died, in the OCA and the other Orthodox churches on the new calendar.
- Dec19
The day he died, in the Russian Church, on the old calendar. Also the Coptic Church, on 10 Kiahk in its own calendar.
Why two feasts? 6 December is the day he died. 9 May is the day his bones reached Bari in 1087, and on that day in Bari the liquid called manna is drawn from his tomb. Churches on the old calendar keep each date 13 days later, so they fall on 19 December and 22 May. The Orthodox Church in America (OCA) also remembers his birth on 29 July. The Greek Church did not take up 9 May. It saw the loss of his relics “as a sad event”, says the OCA.
what was he like?
+generous, and secret about it
In the oldest full account of his life, he gave his inheritance away. The best-known gift was gold thrown by night into a poor man's house, to give his three daughters their dowries. When the father caught him, Nicholas “required him not to tell nor discover this thing as long as he lived”. The Orthodox Church in America's life of him says he always tried to give in secret.
The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas; OCA, 6 December+unafraid of the powerful
In the oldest story told of him, he stopped an execution with his own hands. Then he went to the governor who had been bribed to order it. He “found the gates closed, which anon he opened by force”, and rebuked the man until he repented. Later, in a dream, he threatened the emperor Constantine with war unless he freed three generals condemned on a false charge.
Praxis de stratelatis, as the Golden Legend tells it+a shepherd to his city
Three of the emperor's generals and their troops were stuck in his port, waiting for a wind, and there was plundering and a riot in the town. Nicholas went down to the harbour and invited the generals to come up to Myra and dine with him.
The Golden Legend says he did it “for he would keep his people from the ravin that they made”, that is, from their plundering. In the oldest telling, his gentle words won the soldiers over. They called on everyone to be quiet and went up with him, and the riot ended. In a famine, he talked the captains of the grain ships into sharing their cargo.
The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas+hard on the old gods
In the Golden Legend the people of his province still kept pagan customs. They sacrificed to Diana, the goddess the Greeks called Artemis, under a sacred tree. Nicholas made them stop, and “commanded to cut off the tree”. The older Life by Michael the Archimandrite, the oldest full account of his life, goes further: there he tears down the temple of Artemis at Myra itself.
The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas+strict with himself
Of his life as a bishop, the Golden Legend says: “He woke in prayer and made his body lean, he eschewed company of women, he was humble in receiving all things, profitable in speaking, joyous in admonishing, and cruel in correcting.”
The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas+humble
When sailors he had saved from a storm came to thank him, “he bade them to attribute it to the mercy of God, and to their belief, and nothing to his merits”. Chosen bishop, he tried to refuse.
The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholaswhat others said of him
No one who knew him wrote about him. These are voices from the centuries after.
…the largess which Nicholas unto the maidens gave, in order to conduct their youth to honour.
Though he is one of the most popular saints in the Greek as well as the Latin Church, there is scarcely anything historically certain about him except that he was Bishop of Myra in the fourth century.
The Muscovites, who received their account of him from the Greeks, seem to pay a greater veneration to his memory than to that of any other saint who lived since the times of the apostles.
…no saint was more universally honoured in all Christian nations than St. Nicholas.
his life in six moments
Patara, in Lycia
The traditionA rich couple's only child
Accounts of his life place his birth at Patara, a port in Lycia, on the south coast of today's Turkey. His parents were rich Christians, but the accounts cannot agree on their names. The Golden Legend, a medieval book of saints' lives, has Epiphanes and Johane. The Coptic book of saints has Epiphanius and Tona. The Orthodox Church in America has Theophanes and Nonna.
As a baby, says the Golden Legend, he would nurse only once on Wednesdays and once on Fridays, the Church's fast days.
The Golden Legend; Coptic synaxarium, 10 Kiahk; OCA, 6 DecemberPatara
First written AD 700 to 843Gold through the window
His parents died and left him rich, and he set out to give the money away. A neighbour, a nobleman fallen into poverty, could not give his three daughters dowries, the money a bride's family gave with her at marriage. Without them no one would marry the girls, and their father meant to put them to work as prostitutes so the family could live.
One night Nicholas secretly threw a lump of gold, wrapped in a cloth, through a window of the man's house. With it the eldest daughter married. A little later he did the same for the second.
The father now lay awake to learn who was helping him. The third time he heard the gold fall, ran after Nicholas and caught him. He fell at his feet to thank him, and Nicholas made him promise to tell no one as long as he lived.
The story is first told in the Life by Michael the Archimandrite, a monk known only from this book. It is the oldest full account of Nicholas's life. The German scholar Gustav Anrich dated it between AD 814 and 843. The scholar Gerardo Cioffari put it about AD 700.
The Golden Legend; Roger Pearse, after Aart Blom (1998), on the dates of the LivesMyra
First written AD 700 to 843First through the door
By then Nicholas was living at Myra, the chief city of Lycia, say later accounts. When its bishop died, the bishops of the province met to choose another. The bishop who led the choosing heard a voice in the night. It told him to watch the church doors at matins, the night prayers before dawn. The first man to come in, if his name was Nicholas, was to be made bishop.
He kept the doors, and Nicholas came in first. Asked his name, Nicholas gave it, and the bishop told him he would be bishop of Myra. Nicholas refused strongly, but they took him into the church and set him in the bishop's chair.
The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas; OCA, 6 DecemberMyra
First told about AD 900In prison for the faith
Later accounts of his life say he was jailed and tortured under the emperor Diocletian, in the last great persecution of Christians, and freed when Constantine came to power. The story first appears about AD 900. The Coptic book of saints says Diocletian “tortured him severely for many years”, and that he wrote to his church from prison. Alban Butler, a Catholic priest writing in 1756, noted the doubt: “The silence of other authors make many justly suspect these circumstances.”
Roger Pearse, after Aart Blom (1998); Coptic synaxarium, 10 Kiahk; Butler, Lives of the SaintsNicaea
325, if he was thereAt the great council?
In AD 325 the bishops of the Church met at Nicaea, in today's northwest Turkey. They condemned Arius, a priest who taught that the Son of God was created, and so less than the Father. Was Nicholas among them? The Catholic Encyclopedia doubted it: “There is reason to doubt his presence at Nicaea, since his name is not mentioned in any of the old lists of bishops that attended this council.”
The first account of his life to put him there is a speech in his praise by Nicetas of Paphlagonia, a bishop, written before AD 890. His name does stand in one early list, kept by Theodore the Reader, a church historian of about AD 500, but only in a copy made in the 1200s. The German scholar Gustav Anrich took it for a later addition. The scholar Gerardo Cioffari holds it genuine.
Of eleven medieval copies of the lists, three name him. The Orthodox and Coptic Churches count him among the fathers of the council: “he was one of the 318 fathers assembled there”.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1911); Roger Pearse, after Aart Blom (1998); Jona Lendering, Early Evidence; Coptic synaxarium, 10 KiahkMyra
First written AD 700 to 843The temple of Artemis
The Life by Michael the Archimandrite, the oldest full account of his life, says he destroyed the temple of Artemis at Myra. Artemis was the Greek goddess the Romans called Diana.
That part at least has a real setting. Myra had a temple of Artemis, shown on a coin of the emperor Gordian III. The Dutch historian Jona Lendering notes that the Life names real places in and around Myra. Its story of the famine mentions the granaries at Andriake, Myra's harbour, and archaeologists have dug them up. So the Life, Lendering argues, rests on an account by someone who knew Myra well.
Jona Lendering, Early Evidence, after Cioffari (1987) and Blom (1998)
his miracles
The East calls him the Wonderworker. In the thousand years after his death, at least 50 miracle stories grew up around him. None was written down in his lifetime. Most of those below are told as the Golden Legend, a book of saints' lives compiled in Italy in the 1260s, told them. Two later legends are marked as later. The book itself admits where its story came from: Greek writers, and John the Deacon, who put it into Latin and added many things of his own.
And the doctors of Greece write his legend, and some others say that Methodius the patriarch wrote it in Greek, and John the deacon translated it into Latin and adjousted thereto many things.
3 scenes in his oldest story
-
Myra
When the generals called at MyraThe sword taken away
The emperor Constantine sent three generals, Nepotian, Ursyn and Apollyn, to put down a revolt. Contrary winds held their ships in Myra's port, and there was plundering and a riot in the town. Nicholas went down to the harbour and invited the generals to come up to Myra and dine with him. His gentle words won the soldiers over. They called for quiet and went up with him, and the riot ended.
Meanwhile the governor, bribed, had condemned three innocent men to be beheaded. Nicholas heard of it and hurried to the place of execution with the generals. The three men knelt blindfolded, and the executioner had his sword raised over them. Nicholas ran up, took the sword out of the executioner's hand, threw it away and untied the men.
Then he went to the governor's hall, forced open its closed gates and rebuked him to his face. The governor repented, and at the generals' plea Nicholas forgave him. The generals sailed on with his blessing.
“took the sword out of his hand, and threw it from him, and unbound the innocents”
Seen by the three generals, who had come with him.
Praxis de stratelatis, as the Golden Legend tells it -
Constantinople
After the warThe generals condemned
The three generals put down the revolt without bloodshed and came home to Constantinople in honour. Men at court envied them. They accused the generals of treason and, with bribes, turned the emperor against them. Constantine had them jailed and ordered them killed that same night, without a trial.
When their jailer told them, they tore their clothes and wept. Then Nepotian, one of the three, remembered how Nicholas had saved three innocent men at Myra. He urged the others to call on Nicholas for help, and they prayed to him.
“then Nepotian remembered him how S. Nicholas had delivered the three innocents”
Praxis de stratelatis, as the Golden Legend tells it -
Constantinople
That same nightA bishop in the emperor's dream
That night Nicholas came to the emperor Constantine in a dream. He asked why Constantine had condemned three innocent men, and told him to stop the execution at once. If Constantine did not, Nicholas would pray God to send a war in which the emperor would be overthrown. Constantine asked who dared to enter his palace by night and speak so. The visitor answered that he was Nicholas, bishop of Myra.
The same night Nicholas came in a dream to the prefect, the high official who had agreed to the killing, and threatened him too. The two men woke and told each other their dreams.
Constantine suspected the prisoners had sent the dreams by sorcery. He sent for them and asked what magic they had used. None, they said, and they had done nothing to deserve death. Did they know a man named Nicholas? At the name they raised their hands and prayed to be saved through his prayers.
Constantine set them free and sent them to Nicholas with gifts, to ask him to pray for the emperor, not threaten him. The generals knelt at Nicholas's feet and told him everything, and he gave thanks to God.
“I am Nicholas bishop of Mirea.”
Constantine and his prefect, each in his own dream.
Praxis de stratelatis, as the Golden Legend tells it
The story of Constantine's three generals is known by its Latin title, the Praxis de stratelatis, the story of the generals. It went round on its own long before any full account of his life. The German scholar Gustav Anrich dated the version we have to between AD 460 and 580. The scholar Gerardo Cioffari put it earlier, before about AD 450. The 1916 Roman Martyrology still tells it on his day. Roger Pearse, after Aart Blom (1998); Roman Martyrology (1916), 6 December
Sailors in a storm
A ship was sinking in a storm. The sailors called on Nicholas, whom they knew only by his fame: if what they had heard of him was true, let him prove it now. At once a man who looked like him appeared on board. He helped them work the ship, and the storm died away.
Later the sailors came to his church and knew Nicholas at once, though they had never seen him before. They thanked him, and he told them to thank God's mercy and their own faith, not him. On board, the man had said:
“Lo! see ye me not? ye called me”The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas
Oil from his tomb
When Nicholas was buried in a marble tomb, the Golden Legend says, oil sprang from his body, from head to foot, and healed the sick. The next bishop of Myra, a good man, was driven out by envious rivals, and the oil stopped. When he was brought back, it flowed again.
His bones now lie in Bari, in Italy, where a liquid is still drawn from the tomb every year.
“a fountain of oil sprang out from the head unto his feet; and unto this day holy oil issueth out of his body, which is much available to the health of sicknesses of many men”The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas
Grain that did not run short
Famine struck Myra and its province. Ships loaded with wheat for the emperor put in at the harbour. Nicholas asked each ship for a hundred measures to feed the hungry.
The sailors were afraid: the grain had been measured, and they had to account for all of it at the emperor's granaries in Alexandria. Nicholas promised, in God's name, that nothing would be missing when they got there. They gave the wheat. At Alexandria their cargo measured as full as when they had loaded it, and they told the emperor's officials of the miracle.
Back at Myra, Nicholas shared the wheat out to each by need. It lasted two years, with enough to sell and enough to sow. The story is first told in the Life by Michael the Archimandrite, the oldest full account of his life. The Golden Legend says of the wheat:
“it sufficed for two years, not only for to sell, but also to sow”The Golden Legend; Michael the Archimandrite's Life, as listed by Roger Pearse after Blom
A later legend: the three schoolboys
The most painted of his wonders is in none of the early Greek accounts of his life, and not in the Golden Legend. Its simplest form is in the French Life of Nicholas by Wace, a Norman poet, of about 1150.
Three clerks, schoolboys training for the Church, stop at an inn on their way to school. In the night the innkeeper kills them for their money and hides the bodies. God shows Nicholas what has happened. Nicholas comes at once and asks the innkeeper for the three boys. Unable to hide his crime, the innkeeper shows him the bodies. Nicholas prays, and the boys' souls return to their bodies.
The story also appears in Latin hymns of the 1000s and in a Latin play of about 1100 from Hildesheim, in Germany. Later tellers made the killer a butcher, who cut up the boys and salted them in a tub like meat, until Nicholas raised them whole. Wace's version begins, in our translation:
“Three clerks were going to school”Wace, Life of St Nicholas, about 1150, as printed by Joel Fredell; Roger Pearse, after Fredell and Charles W. Jones; Britannica
A later legend: the boy carried home
A rich man had a son he credited to the prayers of St Nicholas, and named him Deus dedit, God gave. The father built a chapel to Nicholas in his house and kept the saint's feast every year. The family lived near a foreign border. The boy was taken prisoner across it and made to serve the king of that land.
A year later, on the feast of St Nicholas, the boy stood before the king holding a precious cup. The boy thought of home, where his family would be keeping the feast, and sighed. The king asked why, and the boy told him. Whatever your Nicholas does, the king said, you will stay here with us.
At once a great wind shook the house. The boy was swept away, cup in hand, and set down at the gate of his father's house, where the feast was going on, and all there rejoiced. The Golden Legend tells this among the wonders after Nicholas's death:
“the child was ravished with the cup, and was set tofore the gate where his father held the solemnity of S. Nicholas”The Golden Legend, Life of St Nicholas
his words
He wrote nothing that survives. These are the words the stories give him, in the Golden Legend as William Caxton put it into English in 1483, edited by F. S. Ellis in 1900.
To the captains of the grain ships
Do this that I have said to you, and I promise, in the truth of God, that it shall not be lessed or minished when ye shall come to the garners.
Myra was starving. The captains feared to give away the emperor's wheat, because it would be measured again at Alexandria.
The Golden Legend, Life of St NicholasI have to name Nicholas.
Thou enemy of God, corrupter of the law, wherefore hast thou consented to so great evil and felony, how darest thou look on us?
Wherefore hast thou taken these three princes with so great wrong, and hast judged them to death without trespass?
myths and misquotes
He punched Arius at the Council of Nicaea.
What the sources sayA late legend. No early source says he struck anyone. The story first appears about 1370, in a Latin book of saints by Petrus de Natalibus.There Nicholas, an old man at the Council of Nicaea, strikes quemdam Arrianum, a certain Arian, on the jaw. Arians followed Arius, the priest the council condemned. For the blow the council takes away his mitre and pallium, a bishop's tall hat and the woollen band he wears over his shoulders.Arius himself first takes the blow in a Greek Life by a monk named Damaskenos, printed in 1570. It was a slap, not a punch. There Nicholas is stripped of his rank and jailed. That night Christ and the Mother of God come to him in prison and give him a Gospel book and a bishop's stole, and next day he is set free.The scene became part of Orthodox icons. The Orthodox Church in America tells it as tradition. Nicholas, it says, spoke against Arius and “struck him upon the face”. He lost the signs of his rank, and had them given back by Christ and the Mother of God.The historian Jona Lendering thinks a memory may lie behind it: “this anecdote is embarrassing, and this is a reason why it is unlikely to have been invented”.
Roger Pearse (2015), after Gustav Anrich, Hagios Nikolaos (1913); OCA, 6 December; Jona Lendering, Early EvidenceHe was abbot of Holy Sion, a monastery founded by his uncle, a bishop.
What the sources sayNo, that is another Nicholas: Nicholas of Sion, abbot of Holy Sion near Myra and bishop of Pinara, in the 500s. His own Life, written about AD 564, speaks of the tomb of the older Nicholas. A Greek writer of the 800s or 900s wove the two lives into one, and the joined story is still told, as in the Orthodox Church in America's life of him.
Roger Pearse, after Aart Blom (1998); OCA, 6 DecemberHe died a martyr.
What the sources sayNo. No account of his life says so. In later accounts he is jailed and tortured, and lives to go home. He dies in peace at Myra. The 1916 Roman Martyrology calls him “bishop and confessor”, the old title for a saint who was not a martyr.
Roman Martyrology (1916), 6 December; the Golden Legend; Coptic synaxarium, 10 Kiahkfriends, family and rivals
The first Christian emperor. In the oldest story told of Nicholas, the bishop comes to him in a dream and saves three of his generals from execution.
Praxis de stratelatis; the Golden LegendConstantine's three generals, as the Golden Legend names them. They saw Nicholas stop an execution at Myra. Later, condemned to death on a false charge of treason, they prayed to him, and he came to the emperor in a dream and saved them.
The Golden Legend, Life of St NicholasA priest of Alexandria who taught that the Son of God was created, and so less than the Father. The Council of Nicaea condemned his teaching in AD 325. The story that Nicholas slapped one of his followers is first told about 1370, and that he slapped Arius himself in the 1500s.
Jona Lendering, Early Evidence; Roger Pearse (2015), after Gustav AnrichAbbot of Holy Sion near Myra and bishop of Pinara, in the 500s. His Life, written about AD 564, speaks of the tomb of the older Nicholas. Later writers merged the two men into one.
Roger Pearse, after Aart Blom (1998)how he died
He died at Myra on 6 December, some time in the 300s. No record from his own time gives the year, and no source says what he died of.
The Golden Legend tells a peaceful death. He prayed the Lord to send His angels, and bowed his head as he saw them coming. Then he began Psalm 31, In te Domine speravi (In You, Lord, I have taken refuge), and died as he reached its fifth verse.
The book puts his death in AD 343. The Orthodox Church in America's life says he reached old age and died in peace.
He was buried in a church outside the city walls. The Dutch historian Jona Lendering explains why that matters.
Roman law still forbade burials inside a city in the early 300s. Only from about the middle of the century, once Christianity had clearly won, did Christians build churches with tombs inside towns. So a tomb outside the walls suggests that people began to honour him there early, perhaps soon after his death. The church over it still stands in Demre.
His last words, in the Golden Legend
Lord, into Thine hands I commend my spirit
The words of Psalm 31:5, which Jesus prayed on the cross.
his bones: from myra to bari
In 1087 sailors from Bari, a port in southern Italy, carried most of his bones across the sea. They are still in Bari, and every May a little liquid is drawn from the tomb.
The raid of 1087
By 1087 the Turks held Lycia. Merchants of Bari, sailing home from Antioch, put in near Myra in April 1087. Forty-seven armed men went up to the church, where four monks kept the tomb. They offered the monks 300 gold coins, and the monks refused. So the men tied them up and broke open the tomb.
The townspeople ran to the shore too late. On 9 May 1087 the relics were carried into Bari. To the men of Bari it was a rescue: they meant, says the Orthodox Church in America, “to save the relics of Saint Nicholas”. To the Greeks it was a loss.
Alban Butler, a Catholic priest writing in 1756, said the raid “could only be justified by the laws of a just war”. He named a second ground beside it: the fear that the Muslims now ruling Lycia would desecrate the relics.
“they opened it and found the bones swimming in the oil, and they bare them away honourably into the city of Bari”The Golden Legend; OCA, 9 May; Butler, Lives of the Saints; Britannica
The manna
A clear liquid gathers in his tomb. The Greeks call it myron, and Bari calls it manna. Each 9 May since 1980 it has been drawn out in front of a Catholic and an Orthodox bishop: no more than about 50 ml a year. Mixed with blessed water, it is bottled for the sick.
Scientists at the University of Bari found in 1925 that it is water. Britannica calls it most likely condensation, since the tomb lies below ground in a port city. The basilica's own study centre answers that the casket has been proven watertight. Earlier, the Catholic Encyclopedia of 1911 had called it oil:
“an oily substance, known as Manna di S. Nicola, which is highly valued for its medicinal powers, is said to flow from them”St. Nicholas Center, Devotion and Use of Manna; Britannica, on the manna; Catholic Encyclopedia (1911)
Venice, and a bone in Illinois
Bari has most of his bones, but not all. The church of San Nicolò al Lido in Venice keeps as many as 500 fragments. An anatomical study found they fit with the bones in Bari, as if from one body.
In 2017 Oxford scientists dated one of the smaller relics: a piece of pelvis kept at Morton Grove, Illinois, which had come from Lyon. It dates from the 300s. Bari has the upper part of the left hip bone. This piece is from the lower part, so the two could come from one person. The scientists did not claim it was his for certain:
“Science is not able to definitely prove that it is, it can only prove that it is not”University of Oxford, press release of 5 December 2017
how he became santa claus
Each step from Nicholas to Santa Claus is in print. How the steps join is argued over. Here are the texts, and each side in its own words.
A children's saint
In the Middle Ages his feast became a schoolboys' day. Wace, a Norman poet, wrote a French Life of Nicholas in verse about 1150. He ties the custom to the legend of the three schoolboys Nicholas raised from the dead.
After the Reformation, says Britannica, his feast died out in every Protestant country of Europe but one. Holland kept him, as Sinterklaas. In George McKnight's English of 1917, Wace says:
“Because he did such honor to schoolboys, they celebrate this day by reading and singing and reciting the miracles of St. Nicholas.”Wace, Life of St Nicholas, as quoted by George H. McKnight (1917), in Roger Pearse; Britannica
Irving's New York
Washington Irving's comic History of New York, of 1809, made St Nicholas the patron of New Amsterdam, the Dutch town that became New York. In later editions, from 1812, Irving gave him more to do. In the text we read today he rides over the treetops, drops presents down chimneys, and in a dream lays “his finger beside his nose”. The book says:
“for the good St. Nicholas has ever been a great giver of gifts, particularly to children”Washington Irving, A History of New York, book 2 (later edition); Tom A. Jerman, History News Network
The poem of 1823
On 23 December 1823 the Troy Sentinel, a New York paper, printed an unsigned poem, “Account of a Visit from St. Nicholas”. By the mid-1800s it was known as the work of Clement Clarke Moore, a New York professor. It has a sleigh, eight reindeer and a trip down the chimney.
Two of the reindeer were first called “Dunder and Blixem”, old Dutch words for thunder and lightning. Later they became Donner and Blitzen. The poem itself never says Santa Claus. It says St. Nicholas and St. Nick. The editor's note above it says “Sante Claus”. Two years before, in 1821, a poem in a New York booklet had shown “Santeclaus” in a sleigh pulled by a flying reindeer.
“He was chubby and plump, a right jolly old elf, And I laugh'd when I saw him in spite of myself”Troy Sentinel, 23 December 1823; Tom A. Jerman, History News Network; Wikipedia, Santa Claus
Who made Santa?
The older view is that Dutch settlers brought Sinterklaas to New Amsterdam, the Dutch town that became New York. Britannica says so, and so does the Episcopal Church: “his name was brought to America by the Dutch colonists in New York”.
In 1954 Charles W. Jones, a scholar of St Nicholas, answered that there is no proof the colonists kept the custom. He gave the credit to Irving: “Without Irving there would be no Santa Claus.”
In 2020 the historian Tom A. Jerman answered Jones in turn. Jones had argued that Irving's book of 1809 set off the first St Nicholas poems printed in New York, in December 1810. One was a Dutch verse printed for the New-York Historical Society. But the gift-giving passages Jones relied on first appear in Irving's edition of 1812, too late to have inspired them.
Santa, Jerman says, came instead from the rough, fur-clad gift-bringers of Protestant Germany, whom German immigrants brought to America. He took shape in two New York poems: the 1821 booklet's “Santeclaus” and the poem of 1823. In Jerman's words, “St. Nicholas and Santa Claus were two different characters”.
Britannica; Lesser Feasts and Fasts 2022; Charles W. Jones (1954); Tom A. Jerman, History News Networkis he a saint?
Yes. Catholics, Orthodox, Copts and Anglicans count him a saint, and Lutherans remember him too.
- CatholicSaintAn optional memorial on 6 December
- OrthodoxSaintThe Wonderworker, 6 December, and in some churches 9 May
- CopticSaint10 Kiahk, which is 19 December
- AnglicanSaint6 December, in the Church of England
- LutheranRememberedMissouri Synod and ELCA, 6 December
His honour began at his tomb in Myra. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that his name occurs in the Liturgy of St John Chrysostom, the Orthodox Church's usual Sunday service. The Russian Church honours him in particular every Thursday of the year, says the Orthodox Church in America.
Rome's calendar of 1969 notes that the Byzantine and Coptic rites keep 6 December, the day of his death. For the Copts, and for churches on the old calendar, that day falls on our 19 December. In the West, it says, his feast spread from the 900s, most of all after his relics came to Bari in 1087. The old Roman Martyrology gives him this line:
At Myra, the metropolis of Lycia, the birthday of St. Nicholas, bishop and confessor, of whom it is related, among other miracles, that, while at a great distance from the emperor Constantine, he appeared to him in a vision and moved him to mercy so as to deter him from putting to death some persons who had implored his assistance.
what to read first
The Life of S. Nicholas the Bishop
Jacobus de Voragine, in Caxton's English
The Golden Legend's chapter on him: the dowries, the generals, the storm and the grain ships, as the Middle Ages told them. About fifteen minutes.
Read it freeSt. Nicholas
Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints
An 18th-century priest sorts the stories, and tells the raid on Myra from the accounts written at Bari.
Read it freeAccount of a Visit from St. Nicholas
Clement Clarke Moore
The poem as the Troy Sentinel first printed it, unsigned, in 1823, with the editor's note on “Sante Claus”.
Read it freeSt. Nicholas of Myra
Catholic Encyclopedia, 1911
One short page: what is certain, what is legend, and the manna of Bari.
Read it freetake the quizzes
Quiz Which early Christianthinks like you? And which would argue with you? Start
Quiz ChristianPersonality Test Which of eight types are you? Find your own. Start
sources
His life, and the stories
- Jacobus de Voragine, The Golden Legend, “The Life of S. Nicholas the Bishop”. Compiled about 1260, tr. William Caxton (1483), ed. F. S. Ellis (1900).
- Alban Butler, Lives of the Saints, “St. Nicholas”, 1756 to 1759; 1866 edition.
- Roger Pearse, The literary development of the Life of St Nicholas, after Aart Blom, Nikolaas van Myra en zijn tijd (1998), with the dates of Gustav Anrich (1913 and 1917) and Gerardo Cioffari (1987).
- Roger Pearse, Did St Nicholas of Myra punch Arius at the Council of Nicaea?, 2015, with the texts of Petrus de Natalibus and Damaskenos.
- Roger Pearse, St Nicholas and the story of the three schoolboys, 2019, with Wace, McKnight (1917) and Joel Fredell.
- Jona Lendering, Early Evidence, St. Nicholas Center, from Livius.
- Procopius, Buildings, Book 1, chapter 6. Tr. H. B. Dewing, 1940.
- Dante, Purgatorio, canto 20. Tr. Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, 1867.
- Washington Irving, A History of New York, first printed 1809; a later edition.
- Account of a Visit from St. Nicholas, Troy Sentinel, 23 December 1823.
- Tom A. Jerman, Revisiting the Knickerbocker Origin Story of Santa Claus, History News Network, quoting Charles W. Jones (1954).
- University of Oxford, Could ancient bones suggest Santa was real?, 5 December 2017.
- St. Nicholas Center, Devotion and Use of Manna, from Gerardo Cioffari and the Centro Studi Nicolaiani, Basilica of San Nicola, Bari.
Reference
- Catholic Encyclopedia, 1911, “St. Nicholas of Myra”
- Britannica, “St. Nicholas”
- Britannica, “Do the Relics of Saint Nicholas Really Emit a Holy Substance?”
- Merriam-Webster, “Saint Nicholas” and “Myra”, for how to say them
Calendars
- USCCB, Liturgical Calendar 2026, Saint Nicholas, Bishop, 6 December
- Calendarium Romanum, 1969, on 6 December
- The Roman Martyrology, 1916 edition, 9 May and 6 December
- OCA, Saint Nicholas the Wonderworker, Archbishop of Myra in Lycia
- OCA, the Translation of the Relics of Saint Nicholas to Bari
- CopticChurch.net, the Coptic synaxarium, 10 Kiahk
- Church of England, Common Worship calendar
- The Episcopal Church, Lesser Feasts and Fasts 2022
- The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, Commemorations
- Evangelical Lutheran Worship, ELCA, the church year (final draft, 2006)
Pictures
- Nikola from 1294, icon by Aleksa Petrov, 1294, from the Church of St Nicholas at Lipnya, near Novgorod. Public domain.
- Saint Nicholas of Bari, Carlo Crivelli, 1472. Cleveland Museum of Art. Public domain.
- Saint Nicholas of Myra saves three innocents from death, Ilya Repin, 1888. State Russian Museum, St Petersburg. Public domain.
- Saint Nicholas Providing Dowries, Bicci di Lorenzo, 1433 to 1435. The Metropolitan Museum of Art. CC0.






