Sign Up My Profile
The nave of a Catholic parish church: pews and a red carpet leading up to the high altar and its crucifix, statues of saints, and a painted Gothic vault Catholic
The painted interior of a Byzantine church: Christ Pantocrator in the dome, ringed by angels and prophets, above arches of saints and the great cross of the iconostasis Orthodox
Compare traditions

Catholic vs Orthodox: What is the difference?

The pope, the filioque and how doctrine grows: what really separates Catholic and Orthodox Christians, and the five things they hold together.

Pictures: Nativity of Mary, Blessed Virgin Catholic Church, High Hill, Texas, photographed by Carol M. Highsmith. Library of Congress, Washington. Christ Pantocrator in the dome of Panagia tou Arakos, Lagoudera, Cyprus, 1192, photographed for Dumbarton Oaks, 1981.

at a glance

The split BothA slow drift; 1054 is the textbook date
The pope CatholicPeter's successor, with authority over the whole church OrthodoxFirst in honour while the church was one, never in command
The Nicene Creed CatholicLatin rite: the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son OrthodoxThe Spirit proceeds from the Father, as the councils wrote it
Councils accepted CatholicTwenty-one, most recently Vatican II, 1962 to 1965 OrthodoxSeven, the last at Nicaea in AD 787
Infants CatholicBaptised; in the Latin rite, first communion around seven OrthodoxBaptised, anointed with holy oil, and given communion from then on
Priests CatholicLatin rite: celibate as a rule; Eastern Catholic: often married OrthodoxMay marry before ordination, not after; bishops are unmarried
Sunday worship CatholicLatin rite Mass: under an hour, often kneeling OrthodoxDivine Liturgy: sung almost throughout, most people standing

Who this page means. Here, Catholic means the church in communion with Rome, the Latin rite and the twenty-three Eastern Catholic churches alike. Orthodox means the Eastern Orthodox communion, Greek, Russian, Serbian, Romanian, Antiochian and the rest; the Oriental Orthodox churches, which parted earlier still, are a separate communion and are not covered here.

six big questions

Where each one stands on the six questions the denomination quiz asks.

Catholic Orthodox Both, at the same point The middle: no lean either way

Catholic: synergist-leaning Orthodox: firmly synergist

Both: sacramental

Both: continuationist

Both: one-people-of-God

Both: rooted in Scripture and tradition

Both: liturgical

common ground

  • Both receive Christ's body and blood at the altar.

    Both hold that the bread and the cup at the altar are the body and blood of Christ, and neither will call the Supper a symbol. Both baptise infants. In an Orthodox parish the baby is chrismated at the same service, anointed with holy oil as the East's form of confirmation, and is given communion from that day on.

  • Neither reads the Bible on its own.

    Scripture here belongs to the church that recognised which books belong in it, and its meaning has been kept by the creeds, by the councils the whole church received, and by the Fathers, the teachers of its first centuries.

  • Sunday is a liturgy rather than a programme.

    Both keep a fixed order, a calendar of feasts and fasts, readings appointed in advance, and the Eucharist at the centre of the day.

  • Both still expect the Holy Spirit to heal and to startle.

    Neither tradition ever announced that He had stopped, so saints, wonders and prayers answered for the sick belong to ordinary church life rather than to a movement inside it.

  • Israel and the church are one people of God on both sides.

    Neither expects a rapture, or a seven-year tribulation for those left behind.

where they differ

Who brings a person to faith?

How grace and free will fit together

Both say God moves first and that you can still refuse Him; the East never framed it as a contest between God's grace and your will in the first place.

Catholic: synergist-leaning Orthodox: firmly synergist

Catholic

God moves first; the person can refuse

Catholic teaching starts where Orthodoxy does: nothing at the beginning is earned. The Catechism calls grace the free and undeserved help God gives, and Trent taught that justification begins with grace running ahead of anything a person does.

But Trent also condemned the idea that the will is purely passive and cannot refuse its consent. That refusal is what brings Catholics close to the Orthodox here. Centuries of Western argument, first with Pelagius and later with the Reformers, left Catholics stating it as a careful balance: God moves first, and the person can still say no.

Orthodox

Synergy: God and the person work together

The East has one word for it, synergy, from the Greek for working together, and it is older than the Western argument rather than a compromise between its sides.

God's grace does everything, and the person must genuinely cooperate with it; the Synod of Jerusalem in 1672 answered a Calvinist confession by saying God predestines according to His foreknowledge of how each person will use their freedom. Behind that stands theosis: salvation is not only being forgiven but being drawn into the very life of God.

other differences

  • The pope

    Catholics hold that the bishop of Rome is Peter's successor with real authority over the whole church, and the First Vatican Council defined in 1870 that he teaches without error when he speaks solemnly on faith and morals.

    The Orthodox communion has no such office: its churches govern themselves, its patriarchs are equals, and the Patriarch of Constantinople is first in honour rather than in command. Orthodox Christians grant Rome an honoured place in the undivided church. What they deny is that it ever carried command over the rest.

  • The filioque

    One Latin word, in the one text both sides say every Sunday. The Nicene Creed as the councils wrote it says the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father; the West added that He proceeds from the Father and the Son, which in Latin is filioque.

    Orthodox Christians object twice over, to the teaching and to the fact that a creed settled by an ecumenical council was altered without one. Catholics answer that the addition guards the Son's place and makes no second source inside God.

  • How far doctrine may grow

    Orthodoxy recognises seven ecumenical councils, the last at Nicaea in AD 787, and holds that the faith was delivered whole and is guarded rather than added to. The Catholic Church has gone on defining: the Immaculate Conception in 1854, papal infallibility in 1870, the Assumption of Mary in 1950.

    Catholics see those as the same faith made explicit, which is what development of doctrine means. Orthodox Christians see the defining itself as the problem, since not one of them came from a council both halves of the church attended.

how they came to differ

  1. 800s to 1054

    A long drift, then excommunications in 1054

    The two halves of the church did not fall out on a date. They drifted. Greek East and Latin West prayed in different languages, answered to different capitals, and by the ninth century were arguing about the Creed and about how far Rome's authority reached. In 1054 a papal legation and the Patriarch of Constantinople excommunicated each other, and that is the year in every textbook.

  2. 1204 to 1453

    Constantinople sacked; reunion at Florence fails

    What made the break stick came later. In 1204 the Fourth Crusade sacked Constantinople and installed a Latin ruler in a Greek city. Reunion was signed at the Council of Florence in 1439 by an emperor and bishops who needed Western help against the Turks, and the faithful at home would not have it. Constantinople fell in 1453 anyway.

  3. 1965

    The excommunications lifted, not the split

    The anathemas of 1054 have been gone since 7 December 1965, when a joint declaration of Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I was read out at the same hour in Rome and in Constantinople, committing them to oblivion. The two churches are still not in communion. A Catholic and an Orthodox Christian who stand together on so much still cannot receive at one another's altars.

walking in

What a visitor meets on a Sunday morning.

Catholic

A Catholic Mass runs under an hour: pews, a printed order, two readings, a psalm and a Gospel set years in advance so that Manila and Munich hear the same one, a homily, then communion in a line or at a rail. Kneeling is common and there is holy water at the door.

Orthodox

An Orthodox Divine Liturgy is sung almost end to end, usually unaccompanied, in a church covered with icons and thick with incense. Most people stand, the priest chooses almost nothing, babies are carried to the chalice, and everyone leaves with a piece of blessed bread.

Did you know?

Catholic does not mean Latin. The communion is made of twenty-four self-governing churches: the Latin one most Westerners picture, and twenty-three Eastern Catholic churches with their own liturgies, their own canon law and, in many of them, married priests.

what we read

Catholic

  • The Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992)

    Numbered by paragraph, so a reference lands exactly: 1996 to 2001 on grace, 1374 to 1376 on the Eucharist.

  • The Council of Trent, Decree on Justification (1547)

    Grace runs ahead of everything a person does, and the will can still withhold its consent.

  • Dei Verbum (1965)

    The Second Vatican Council on Scripture and tradition flowing from one source.

Orthodox

  • The Synod of Jerusalem (1672)

    The East's answer to Calvinism: God predestines according to His foreknowledge of a free will.

  • John of Damascus, An Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith

    Eighth century and still the standard summary. Book IV covers baptism and the Eucharist.

  • The Divine Liturgy of St John Chrysostom

    The text sung on most Sundays of the year, and the fastest way to meet Orthodoxy from the inside.

other comparisons

All comparisons

Suggest a correction

Berean Standard Bible