Liturgical churches follow a set order and the church calendar, with communion at the center of Sunday and prayers the church has used for centuries. Free churches hold that Scripture prescribes no fixed service, so each congregation builds its own around the Bible read and preached, prayer and song.
It is the first thing a visitor notices. In one church everyone prays the same words from a book, the colors change with the season, and the service ends at the Table; in another the shape is the pastor’s to choose, the songs were written this decade, and a member may be asked to speak. Underneath sits an old question: whether a church may do only what Scripture commands, or anything Scripture does not forbid.
Your answers are marked. From your result on . See your result
Where you landed:
Each dot is one tradition, numbered left to right. In the hatched middle the quiz names neither pole.
Liturgical Free
No listed tradition sits here on this axis.
Liturgical worship follows a set order and the church calendar, usually with the Eucharist at the center of the Lord’s Day service, so that the whole congregation prays and sings with the historic church, in words tested over centuries, and joins the worship of heaven. The order is not thought of as a limit on the Spirit but as something the Spirit has already given: most of the words are Scripture, and nobody present has to hope the person at the front is at their best this week.
Free worship holds that Scripture prescribes no fixed liturgy, so each congregation orders its own service around the Word read and preached, prayer, song, and the ordinances; some keep a plain, settled pattern and others leave the shape open for the Spirit to lead in the moment, with room for any member to contribute. The instinct behind it is that a service should be able to answer what God is doing in this congregation this week, and that a form nobody may change can become a form nobody means.
Zwingli stopped the singing in Zurich, and he was the best musician of the Reformers. He played ten instruments and sang well, and he still suspended choir singing in 1525 and had the Grossmünster organ broken up in 1527. Zurich’s churches sang nothing until 1598.
Zurich: choir singing suspended 1525, organ dismantled 9 December 1527, congregational psalms from 1598.
England’s first prayer book in English set off a rebellion. Cranmer’s Book of Common Prayer became compulsory on Whitsunday, 9 June 1549; the West Country rose the next day, and thousands died before the rising was put down.
Act of Uniformity 1549; the Prayer Book Rebellion, Devon and Cornwall, summer 1549.
The oldest church order we have does both at once. The Didache, written within living memory of the apostles, gives set prayers for the Lord’s Supper and then tells the prophets to give thanks in whatever words they like.
Didache 9–10, late first century.
10 moments, from the 1st century to the 20th
Tap one to read it. BSB, public domain since 30 April 2023 (berean.bible/licensing.htm).
Acts 2 · verse 42
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
Acts 20 · verse 7
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
John 4 · verses 23–24
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
1 Corinthians 14 · verses 26–30 of 15 in the passage
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
Colossians 3 · verse 16
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
Hebrews 12 · verse 28
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
Revelation 4 · verses 1–5 of 11 in the passage · the reference spans chapters 4–5
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
Psalm 150 · verses 1–5 of 6 in the passage
Berean Standard Bible (BSB)
