Sign Up My Profile
Albrecht Dürer’s engraving of Saint Jerome writing at his desk, a lion and a dog asleep on the floor of his study

What did the early Christians say about emotions?

They did not agree. Clement of Alexandria, Anthony the Great and 3 others would say yes to the statement below. Lactantius, Jerome and Augustine of Hippo would say no.

  • 8On record
  • 5Would agree
  • 3Would disagree

The statement in the quiz

“The best way to live is free of strong emotions, with only a steady peace inside.”

The quiz puts it in today’s words. Each person below is placed by what they wrote or said. Where their line is clear on its own, it is printed with its source.

5 early Christians

Would agree

Anthony the Great c. AD 251 to 356 · The Egyptian desert

Anthony strongly agrees:

“He was not troubled when he beheld the crowd, nor overjoyed at being saluted by so many. But he was altogether even as being guided by reason, and abiding in a natural state.”

Life of Antony, as Athanasius recorded his words

Martin of Tours c. AD 316 to 397 · Gaul, today’s France

Martin strongly agrees:

“No one ever saw him enraged, or excited, or lamenting, or laughing; he was always one and the same: displaying a kind of heavenly happiness in his countenance, he seemed to have passed the ordinary limits of human nature.”

Life of St Martin, as Sulpicius Severus, who knew him, recorded it

Macrina the Younger c. AD 327 to 379 · Cappadocia

Macrina agrees:

“It will therefore be no detriment to our participation in the Good, that the soul should be free from such emotions.”

On the Soul and the Resurrection, as her brother Gregory recorded her words

John Cassian c. AD 360 to c. 435 · Egypt, then Marseilles

Cassian agrees:

“For patience would not be worthy of praise and admiration if it only preserved its purposed tranquillity when attacked by no darts of enemies, but it is grand and glorious because when the storms of temptation beat upon it, it remains unmoved.”

Conferences

3 early Christians

Would disagree

Augustine of Hippo AD 354 to 430 · North Africa

Augustine strongly disagrees:

“And if that is to be called apathy, where the mind is the subject of no emotion, then who would not consider this insensibility to be worse than all vices?”

City of God

What they said

More questions

All 23 questions, and all 21 early Christians.

your turn

Quiz Which early Christian thinks like you? And which would argue with you? See where you would stand on this and 22 more. Start

Suggest a correction

Berean Standard Bible